Friday Sound-Off: Should Restrictions be Placed on Comfort Animals on Flights?

LAST UPDATED: 4/22/23 – Should Restrictions be Placed on Comfort Animals on Flights?

Comfort Animals on Flights
A young woman reported that she was made to flush her hamster down the toilet after it wasn’t allowed on her flight.

Chances are, you have heard the story by now. A young woman flying home on Spirit Airlines was allegedly told by an airline employee to either set her emotional support hamster free or flush it down the toilet after being told that the animal couldn’t accompany her on a flight. The news hit social media and almost instantly went viral.

It all started when a young college student, Belen Aldecosea, booked her flight home from Baltimore to South Florida. During her first semester of school in Philadelphia, Belen had discovered a large growth on her neck. To take her mind off her health issues as she waited for the biopsy results, she had purchased a small hamster she named Pebbles. Hamsters are commonly used as emotional support animals because of their size and how easy it is to care for them.

In order to make sure that Pebbles would be able to accompany her on her flight back home, Belen had asked the ticketing agent at Frontier Airlines if she could bring Pebbles on the flight. The agent told her that she could.

Fast forward to the day of her flight, and the information from Frontier Airlines was very different. After checking in, she was informed that Pebbles wouldn’t be able to board the flight with her. The airlines did schedule Belen on a later flight to allow her time to make arrangements for the animal, but Belen wasn’t from the area and couldn’t find anyone to care for Pebbles.

That is when Belen says that she was told by an airline employee that, if she wanted to board the plane, she would either need to set the animal free, or flush it down the toilet. Belen, recalling the moment when she had to flush Pebbles down the toilet, said, “I was emotional. I was crying. I sat there for a good 10 minutes crying in the stall.”

Frontier Airlines admits that its ticketing agent incorrectly told Ms. Aldecosea that she could bring her hamster on the flight when she booked, but denies that any of its employees ever suggested that she flush the animal down the toilet. Derek Dombrowski, a spokesman for the airline, responded, “To be clear, at no point did any of our agents suggest this guest (or any other for that matter) should flush or otherwise injure an animal”.

It remains to be seen how this story will play out in the court of public opinion and perhaps in a court of law, but we would like to address the larger questions in relation to this story.

Should airlines allow any comfort animals on flights? Are there any restrictions that an airline should make in its policy? A passenger recently tried to bring an emotional support peacock on a United Airlines flight, but the bird was denied boarding. Should this animal have been allowed on the flight?

What happens when an airline gives a customer incorrect information at booking, but then denies boarding at the time of flight? Should there be more accountability by the airlines for when they make mistakes?

These are all tough questions. Emotional support animals are a very real and very necessary thing. So is the security and safety of passengers aboard a plane. How these two issues get reconciled will be a front-and-center issue for airlines in the coming years, as airlines continue to grapple with what balance to draw.

What are your thoughts on allowing comfort animals on flights?  We definitely see the need for some restrictions, but we also think that airlines need to become much more customer focused.  In this situation, the biggest error was in the airline giving a passenger incorrect information at the time of booking.  This is something that the airline openly admits.  We believe something more should have been done by the airline to accommodate this passenger in light of the details.

In terms of bigger picture, we think the airlines do have an obligation to balance passenger safety with these requests.  For that reason, we do not oppose some restrictions to the carrying of some animals on flights.  However, we also believe that it is the obligation of the airlines to make sure their policies are very clear and understood by their passengers at the time of booking.

Wanderlust Travel and Photos Blog

Don’t Forget to Subscribe to My Adventures!

Join 6,449 other subscribers
Please follow along with our adventures:
Follow by Email
Visit Us
Follow Me
Categories: Air Travel, Airports, Friday Sound-Offs, Opinions, Travel, Travel HealthTags: , , , , , , , , , , ,


  1. Traveling by air is a privilege, not a right. Most animals, if not all, can fly safely in cargo. Am I supposed to believe a person cannot be separated from their comfort animal for a few hours? If they really can’t, maybe they should find a different mode of transportation. That said, I personally don’t mind small, unobtrusive animals on a plane, but some people have allergies to be considered. Large animals – no way!

  2. I agree with Eilene. Airlines ship animals all the time. There are restrictions on the types (dangerous, flat-faced, etc.) of animals and what time of day they can ship; for their own safety. A small rodent in an appropriate cage would not have been a problem to put in the animal cargo area. I’ve shipped puppies and I’ve even flown with a puppy to hand deliver it. He was in the cabin with me but the crate had to fit under the seat in front of me. Several things don’t add up in this story. Nothing and nobody would convince me to EVER kill an animal in a situation like this. She had many other options. I’m not an animal rights nut. An animal is an animal; but it is also a life. The fact that she chose to treat this animal literally like waste is nauseating.

  3. Yes just surprises me the girl would actually kill her pet! Seems off to me but terrible if true…

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

We've detected that you are using AdBlock Plus or some other adblocking software which is preventing the page from fully loading. We don't have any banners, Flash, animation, obnoxious sound, or popup ads. I do not implement these annoying types of ads.

Creating the travel guides, itineraries, and other premium travel content for this blog is a lot of work and it costs money to
host this blog. Almost all of my revenue to run this blog comes from our online advertising.

Don't miss out on any of my premium travel guides, itineraries, and travel advice articles by subscribing to follow my adventures. All these guides will be delivered to your mailbox, hassle-free!

Subscribe To My Adventures!